Comparison · UpGuard alternative

Covenant vs UpGuard

UpGuard built a strong security-ratings platform for mid-market and enterprise security teams. If you are a clinic, a billing company, or an MSP, you are likely paying enterprise pricing — and a per-vendor surcharge — for a fraction of what you use. Covenant is the flat-priced alternative with native HIPAA BAA tracking.

Side by side

Where each tool fits

CapabilityCovenantUpGuard
Pricing modelFlat per companyPer-vendor add-on (~$79/mo each)
Free tier10 vendors + BAA, foreverTrial only
Self-serve signupYes, no cardSales-led / quote
HIPAA BAA lifecycleNative, freeNot offered
SIG / CAIQ questionnairesIncludedIncluded
External posture scanningTLS / headers / email-auth / breachInternet-wide ratings
Explainable, itemized scoresEvery delta shownRating methodology is opaque
Best forSMBs, clinics, MSPsMid-market / enterprise SOC

Competitor figures from public pricing pages and third-party quotes, 2025–2026. UpGuard and SecurityScorecard are trademarks of their respective owners; Covenant is not affiliated with or endorsed by them.

Why teams switch

The two complaints we hear most

"It costs more every time we add a vendor."

Per-vendor pricing turns a growing vendor list into a growing bill. Covenant is one flat fee — the Team tier is unlimited vendors for $249/mo — so you can register every vendor without watching the meter.

"We can't explain the score to our auditor."

Security-ratings scores can move without a clear cause. Covenant itemizes every factor — inherent exposure, questionnaire, findings, BAA gaps — with a timestamped delta you can hand an auditor.

"It does nothing for our HIPAA BAAs."

If you handle PHI, missing BAAs are an OCR finding waiting to happen. Covenant tracks the full §164.504(e) lifecycle — for free — which ratings platforms simply do not do.

Try the flat-priced alternative.

Start with 10 vendors and full BAA tracking, free, then grow without per-vendor fees.

Start free →